ChemicaLogic Home
spacer.gif (846 bytes)

model comparisons

Comparing Saturated Densities

Comparisons of the saturated liquid densitiy, from the triple point to the critical point is summarized below:

Relative Error
(Liquid Density)

IAPWS-IF97

NBS/NRC-84

IFC-67

Maximum absolute error

2.293%

7.931%

10.907%

Average absolute error

0.123%

0.196%

0.204%

Root Mean Square error

0.407%

0.828%

1.092%

Comparisons of the saturated vapor densitiy, from the triple point to the critical point is summarized below:

Relative Error
(Vapor Density)

IAPWS-IF97

NBS/NRC-84

IFC-67

Maximum absolute error

2.666%

8.000%

11.862%

Average absolute error

0.141%

0.315%

0.341%

Root Mean Square error

0.471%

0.955%

1.276%

Note: The IAPWS-95 formulation is used as the baseline for comparisons.

A chart of the deviations is available in PDF format. Also, the Excel spreadsheet used to generate this summary and chart is also available:

Comparing saturated liquid density (PDF file)

(9 KB; compare_sat_liq_density.pdf; January 22, 1999)

Comparint saturated vapor density (PDS Format Chart)

(13 KB; comapre_sat_vap_density.pdf; January 22, 1999)

Comparing saturated liquid density (Excel file)

(93 KB; compare_sat_liq_density.xls; January 22, 1999)

Comparing saturated vapor density (Excel file)

(93 KB; compare_sat_vap_density.xls; January 22, 1999)